Christina Vs. Lady Gaga

on Thursday, June 3rd, 2010

Christina Aguilera VS. Lady Gaga Debate

Christina Aguilera has been main stream for more than 10 years, yet Lady Gaga has been main stream for a little less than a year.

Who is better? What do you think about Christina Aguilera’s new album? Do you think she is copying Lady Gaga, does it really matter?

  • Kat Walker

    Christina has done weird and experimental things before Gaga’s rise to fame (just watch her creepy ass video for “Fighter”) and her sense of fashion/makeup has always been over-the-top, although much more so in her younger days than after becoming a mother (now she seems to embrace a more mature old-Hollywood glam look).  

    I think Gaga’s crazy wardrobe is more well-received because it’s seen as weird performance art (even if it is partially about attention-whoring), while Christina’s fashion was disconnected from her music and it felt like she was trying too hard to be little miss sex symbol when she was talented enough to not NEED to use sex to sell her music (unlike other blonde pop stars). 

    That, and Christina started out as a teen singer who was marketed to a younger audience, and parents criticized her heavily for being a bad role model even though she never wanted to be one.  It took Christina a very long time to get people to stop expecting that of her.  Gaga’s music was never considered “teen pop”, so she was taken more seriously by the media.

    I admire Christina for getting out of her comfort zone with every new album while Gaga seems to just do the same thing time and time again.  I also happen to think Christina’s music is slightly less shallow – sure she sings about sex and stupid cliche things a lot, but Gaga is very artificial while Christina has had the courage to step out and put her personal life into her music every so often.  
    It’s not like Gaga was the first to come up with expressive, abstract fashion or music.  Both are talented, but it isn’t fair to call Christina a ripoff when both of them are heavily influenced by singers who came before them (like Madonna) and they have different influences as well.  People who argue about who copied who are obviously too young (or too musically illiterate) to know how far back these influences reach.  

  • loveisreal

    really ! they both sing in different ways ! and are original in their own way ! :) who actually cares . if you like gaga – you like gaga ! :) if you like Christina – you like Christina ! :)  

  • dlb

    Lady GaGa . forsurre (:

  • http://STAINLESSSTEEL-KITCHENFAUCET.COM Pearl Mickiewicz

    On the video of Christina Aguilera, I’m glad she isn’t or at least looks like she isn’t doing the whole lady gaga thing. She looks much better being real

  • Jordan

    Christina. I don’t think that Lady Gaga is all that great.

  • http://www.myspace.com/alexis_nicole5140 Alexiss.

    Lady Gaga.

  • kaleigh

    christina

  • http://tcl32u22panasonic.info Lia Mccrain

    I love Christina Aguilera’s video music of You Lost Me. She is absolutely a very talented young woman of this generation. I adore her a lot

  • http://46G300UREVIEWS.INFO Curt Kikuchi

    My all time favorite from Christina Aguilera is ‘What a girl wants’. A great track.

  • http://NellBalensiefen.com Tom Aramboles

    Christine Aguilera is really pretty and she’s great at singing! She is really gifted! She actually got somewhere than Britney Spears

  • erika

    LADY GAGA forever ,always all the way!!!!!!!!!!!!:)

  • Ashley

    ChristinaAgulera has a better voice but i love LadyGaga’s songs more

  • http://MYSPACE EVELYN

    LADY GAGA:)

  • tiffany tice

    Lady Gaga.(:

  • samantha

    Lady Gaga

  • http://myspace Mariah

    GAGA!!!!!!!!!!!

  • http://dontgotone.com chloe.

    GAGA FOR SUREEEE!

  • Bailee

    Lady GaGa!

  • LeticiaBBY

    my gurl LADY GAGA all thee wayy bby..

  • haley

    lady gaga all the way

  • http://www.dirtydebate.com Admin

    Christina Aguilera FTW!